Originally Posted by mikolo-n54
I would say fix the issues with the 335i and you'd be happier with the handling and performance of your car.
But it sounds like you already made up your mind you want a new ride, so non of our advices will stick
Which is ok. They are your dollars after all.
My choice between the cars you chose would be the Subaru if you really want a new one, and want to drive a manual. (Americans and manuals
I still remember this was reversed with Europeans)
Go and have fun with the ST then
I hope you enjoy it to bits. "